A group of schoolchildren was rescued from England’s third-highest mountain after getting into difficulties in winter conditions.
One pupil suffered injuries when he slid down a snow slope.
Rescuers warned that, despite benign conditions in the valleys, the Lake District mountain tops are still in full winter condition.
Keswick Mountain Rescue Team was called out about 5.25pm on Thursday when the group called 999 from Helvellyn.
The team said the party of 13 children and two adults had made the ascent of the mountain from the west side.
A team spokesperson said: “Their route to the summit involved a lot of movement over snow slopes and they then returned ‘off piste’ down steep snow patches and by scrambling over rocky scree.
“Unfortunately, the slope they chose is convex and consequently steepens as you descend. Without crampons or ice-axes to arrest any fall, the group made their way downhill as best they could on the hard snow until one of the group slid out of control coming to rest some 60-80ft lower down, but not before hitting his face and breaking his nose along with breaking a couple of fingers.”
The group called 999 but could not give an exact location. The information given was that a member of the group had slid 50m and had sustained head injuries. Two Keswick MRT vehicles left base and made their way to Swirls car park from where they started to climb towards Helvellyn knowing only that the missing party were somewhere between them and the summit.
A Coastguard helicopter was also called due to the potential seriousness of the incident.
The spokesperson said: “Control were later able to make further contact with the group and were then told that one of the party, on seeing the fall had run off downhill and had not been seen since. Further team members were subsequently tasked to find the missing person who was later found by police.
“It was now dark as team members approached the steep section of Browncove Crags. Voices were heard off to the right of the path on the slopes known as Helvellyn Screes and after donning crampons to negotiate the steep and hard snow slopes the team members found the group huddled in small groups on scree ledges.”
Team members cut steps in the snow slope while rescuers tended to the injured boy. The uninjured children, who were cold and damp, were accompanied one-by-one across the slope to safer ground.
The spokesperson said: “Once the casualty had had his hand splinted and injuries assessed, he was able to walk with assistance. With one team member on either side the casualty was walked off along with the rest of the group back to the main path.
“A reminder that despite that rare sun appearing in the sky, green fields and daffodils emerging down in the valleys the fells are in full winter condition and those venturing above the snow line should be suitably clothed, experienced and prepared.”
The incident involved 22 Keswick MRT volunteers and lasted more than four hours.
Lakeland Walker
07 March 2020Some serious questions need to be asked by the HSE and Police and answered by the two adult "leaders". This could have easily been a fatality of a school child. I thought all organised groups of under 18s were meant to be vetted by AALA and heed the learning points on the HSE website about the Glenridding tragedy. There is no excuse for this type of reckless behaviour that endangers young lives. Were the parents aware that this was the plan for the day? Was the emergency procedures plan really for someone just to run off to find help? Did the adult "leaders" not think that trainers (see the photo in the article) were not suitable for winter conditions in the mountains? https://www.hse.gov.uk/aala/glenridding-beck.htm
Jamie
07 March 2020Adults? Brain dead adults?
Alan
08 March 2020With young children involved, a school party ? , where is the risk assessment ?
The adults should be brought to account. surely they must have
known they were on thin ice ( no pun intended ) coming down
steep icy snow.
If they are teachers, the school organisers must also be scrutinised
Brian
08 March 2020Still?
Louise
08 March 2020Lakeland Walker- schools do not need an AALA license , if they pay for services eg an outdoor company then that business should have an AALA license. If they have used their own teachers then no AALA license required. Therefore the AALA licensing is pretty useless , as these accidents seem to occur when teachers have deemed themselves qualified enough to take their pupils out.
Danny269
08 March 2020The whole point of Summer/Winter Mountain Leader qualifications was introduced in part response to the 1971 Cairngorms disaster... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cairngorm_Plateau_disaster
This sounds like a 'near miss' of a headline such as 2020 Hellvelyn Schoolchildren disaster'... pleased it seems to have been averted with minimal injuries /casualties but If I was a parent of one of the kids I would expect an inquiry into the actions and/or decisions of both the 'two adults' involved as well as the school/organisation behind the venture..
Happy for any person (child or adult) to experience the mountains in winter and summer but there's no excuse these days for organised events such as this appears to have been not to be appropriately managed.
Margaret
08 March 2020Louise,
there is probably more to it than "deemed themselves qualified" as Local Authorities and therefore schools will have their own regulations for undertaking outdoor activities.
As always, it is usually about how those regulations have been applied and qualification, but especially experience, comes into it (eg Glenridding).
Louise
08 March 2020Yes of course, they should have risk assessments in place etc. My point is a scheme was developed (AALA) to protect children but yet it doesn’t cover school or scout groups. So you trust your children are being looked after properly in these situations but this isn’t necessarily the case.
John Paterson
09 March 2020The whole exercise seems to have been ill conceived from start to finish and whoever was in charge clearly did not have either the appropriate training in winter conditions nor, to be honest, a minimal amount of common sense. The worry for me is that the errors committed before and during this incident will not be fully investigated AND BROUGHT TO THE ATTENTION of the head teacher, the board of governors and the education authority.
The other thing that strikes me is that the party "were unable to give an exact location" of the incident. That MIGHT have been understandable when I first started winter walking and climbing but, surely in this day an age it isn't too much to ask that ALL school parties should have a working GPS and the ability to use it - as well as the traditional map and compass?
If I had a child at that school I would want EVIDENCE that lessons had been learned and major changes made (in planning, risk, assessment, equipment and training) before I would allow my child to venture into the great outdoors summer or winter on school trips.
Margaret
09 March 2020Just for interest what AALA (on website) say about schools -
AALA "Teachers leading their own pupils in adventure activities and assuming responsibility for their safety do not have to be licensed. But the school should however ensure that they are competent in the activity which they are leading. The fact that they do not fall within the scope of the regulations does not exempt them from their existing legal duty of care, as a teacher."
Margaret
09 March 2020Danny269 - just for info
Summer/Winter Mountain Leader were started in the mid and late 1960s before the Cairngorm incident.
However, the qualifications were introduced in response to earlier incidents involving young people on the hill.
Christina Goode
10 March 2020— shame on this school; an experienced guide can and should be hired for these school groups. These are innocent children depending and relying on trusting adults. Not withstanding, any guide probably would have advised them not to venture out in full winter conditions.
Chris, Cockermouth
OldManOfTheHills
10 March 2020In Scotland in the Northern Corries and Glenfeshie I recently saw several parties of youngster out in good but full winter conditions. All well equipped and escorted by a suitable adult. No issues at all. Perhaps the Scots are less naïve about winter?
However in the Lakeland incident why, if lacking crampons, did they stray from good ground?
Why was a single child permitted or encouraged to run off alone after the incident?
Someone needs a strong talking too!
The ascent from the West avoids Striding Edge etc but is hardly suitable for ill equipped walkers
Neil B
12 March 2020Do the MRTs do any kind of debrief with these parties. It would be useful to understand their planning process, what information sources they did or didn't use, what equipment they did or didn't think they needed (in this case a group shelter would have helped.
Understanding these issues might help to better target advice and warnings.
NeilB
13 March 2020Do the MRTs do a debrief with the rescuees? It might help target advice if we knew the decision making and planning processes these ill-thought out ventures had undertaken. They must have either researched or had some (inadequate) advance knowledge but perhaps were totally ignorant of the multitude of info sources: MWIS, Lake Felltop Assessor, winter walking guidance etc. It could be helpful to understand these incidents in more depth.
Margaret
14 March 2020NeilB
It's likely the HSE (AALA) will have a look at this incident. If not, then any self-respecting school governors/trustees should be looking closely at the circumstances.
'Target Advice' - as highlighted above the Glenridding accident report is, I think, still on the AALA website and if people search around they will find the full report into the Cairngorm Accident, which has also featured in a number of publications and books.
Always valuable to know what went wrong.
Mark
18 February 2022Follow up: HSE did prosecute in this case.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-60428239
https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-school-fined-after-one-23127266
https://www.grough.co.uk/magazine/2022/02/18/tyneside-school-fined-30000-after-ill-planned-helvellyn-ascent-leads-to-rescue
The failings in this case were appalling and the lack of very severe injury or death was fortuitous. Couple of points of note from the case and the comments above. This was not a mainstream school, which take outdoor activities very seriously after a number of historic tragedies.
They were utterly unprepared for the undertaking in which they were involved. School uniform, two mobile phones and a map are so inadequate for Winter Mountaineering as to be almost beyond comment.
@ Louise: the Scout Association have their own permitting schemes equivalent to ML (S)/ML (W) which are very rigorously implemented.