Acclaimed film-maker and photographer Terry Abraham has resigned from a charity over the planned zipwires at Thirlmere.
The cinematographer announced his decision at the rebranding launch of The Lake District Foundation on Friday.
The organisation was formerly known as Nurture Lakeland and has the stated aims of promoting the conservation, protection and improvement of the physical and natural environment and cultural heritage of the Lake District by providing funding and support for conservation, environmental and cultural initiatives in the Lake District and Cumbria.
It also says it aims to inspire people to care for and contribute to the natural environment and cultural heritage of the Lake District and Cumbria.
Terry Abraham has produced two films on Lakeland peaks – Scafell Pike and Blencathra – which have screened on the BBC, and this year released a biographical work on mountaineer Alan Hinkes. He had been appointed an ambassador to The Lake District Foundation, whose trustees include Lake District national park chief executive Richard Leafe and Ian Stephens, former chief executive of Cumbria Tourism.
But at the launch near Windermere, he announced to the gathering that he was resigning the post. He said later on Twitter that he was not allowed to express his opinion on the controversial plans for the Thirlmere zipwire as the charity wanted to remain neutral.
He told the audience at the launch: “I have to stand against because the idea that it is meant to inspire youth for adventure and appreciation of the outdoors, I find tenuous at best.
“What it’s likely to cost and what’s involved with the ride, never mind the detrimental effects potentially in terms of conservation that it has on the area and the signal that that sends out at large across the whole of the national park and others around the country, I find laughable to a degree.
“You can go gill scrambling, scrambling, climbing, kayaking, mountain biking, fellwalking, wild camping. These things afford more in terms of your mental health, your physical health and inspiring people to appreciate the environment that they’re in, the environment, and nature, conservation, to care and protect.
“I hope that you can understand why I have to decline the role and I do apologise for bringing it over to you this way.”
He went on to point out that Zip World Lakes Limited has already been registered as a company.
“A few months ago I rode the longest zipwire in Europe and the fastest in the world in north Wales, on the edge of the national park, in a working industrial quarry is where that zipwire exists.
“And I did a video, I put it out on social media, saying how much I enjoyed it – it’s fun, I am not anti-zipwire, but – I did make the point – in a suitable location,” he said. “And I wouldn’t like to see something like that bang in the heart of a national park, especially when it’s just been designated world heritage site status.”
He said he subsequently was persuaded to remove the video. He pointed out he was simply stating his opinion, that local people in north Wales who had been in favour of the development now complain about noise from the zipwire.
He added: “[Cumbria Tourism’s] argument for the Thirlmere Activity Hub goes against not just everything I feel I stand for and care about in terms of inspiring people to care for the Lake District, in terms of conservation, and what the national park is about to protect, enhance and conserve.
“Hopefully the planners will adhere to the Sandford Principle.”
Mike Turner, owner of Tree Top Trek which is applying for consent for the zipwires, is a member of the executive board of Cumbria Tourism. The Sandford Principle states that if there is a conflict between protecting the environment and people enjoying the environment that can’t be resolved by management, then protecting the environment is more important.
Mr Abraham, who moved from his Nottinghamshire home to live in Cumbria recently, said: “I’ve wrestled with my conscience, and I wanted to maintain my integrity, and if I can get that message out there then I have done, but don’t doubt I do not care about the Lake District – the blood, sweat and tears I’ve gone through in the last few years to produce the documentaries all by myself. I am beholden to nobody, I am independent.
“I can’t not speak out when it’s a conservation charity.”
A spokesperson for The Lake District Foundation said: “The love of the Lake District runs deep and it’s wonderful that people like Terry have such a passion for the area and such strong views on its future.
“We of course respect his right to express his opinion and wish him well as he begins work on his next film.
“The Lake District Foundation is a neutral organisation that raises funds for the area to distribute to a range of projects. As such, our job is not to campaign on either side of issues such as the proposed zipwire in Thirlmere. There are other highly effective interest groups that exist to do this.
“Therefore, although any of our ambassadors are welcome to express their views as individuals, it is important they don’t use the Lake District Foundation as a platform as it would distract attention from our overall task of raising money for all the good causes we support.
“Friday was a great day in the life of The Lake District Foundation. We received so much support from businesses, partners and local beneficiary projects who are excited about our commitment to generate funds to protect this amazing place.
“Our launch is a step towards our ambitious plans to raise £1 from each of the 18 million visitors to the park each year.”
Mr Abraham said he will make a further statement on Monday.
He told grough that before the YouTube recording started, he addressed the gathering. “I felt compelled to speak out. I spoke about how we’re all standing in the shoulders of giants: Wordsworth sowed the seeds of the idea of national parks; John Muir emigrated and created national parks, we in the UK followed suit; the Kinder mass trespass; the roots of the National Trust; Beatrix Potter fought against the industrialists; and of course the national park we sit amongst today.
“Thirlmere was the birthplace of the conservation movement. Ullswater was planned to be a reservoir.
“I am still now so saddened I had to take that considered but ultimately impulsive decision. I’m genuinely sorry if I upset anyone. But my emotions are inevitably overruled by the bigger picture of what matters in the Lakes.”
A YouTube video of Terry Abraham speaking at the launch has been posted.
Mike V.
16 December 2017I greatly admire Terry Abraham's Lake District Films. I have those he's published to date, and will no doubt buy any future Lakeland films he might make. In my opinion they contain truly outstanding cinematic visualizations of the fantastic scenery that the Lake District National Park is all about.
On his resignation as ambassador for the Lake District Foundation: -
It is refreshing to hear in this day and age where everyone seems to be only out for what they can personally gain, that that someone has remained true to his conscience and his beliefs that this zip-wire proposal is contrary to the ethos of protecting, enhancing, and conserving the Lake District National Park.
Well done that man!
James Bell
16 December 2017I'm not sure Ian Stephens is Cumbria Tourism's Chief Executive :-)
Bob
16 December 2017James, you're correct. Mr Stephens is no longer Cumbria Tourism's chief executive; Gill Haigh is now in that post. Our apologies for the error. We've amended the story to say Mr Stephens is a former chief executive of the body.
Bob Smith
Steve S penrith
16 December 2017I echo Mike V views
simon noble
17 December 2017There appears to be no mechanism for cross-checking the many bodies that operate around the LDNPA, what they call the partnership. And there are certain individuals who are in numerous groups, sub-groups, tourism organisations and other representative bodies. Some individuals resign from one group to reappear elsewhere. It would be very easy for these individuals to manipulate the system for selfish reasons and/or commercial gain without anybody noticing or being able to do anything about it. There appears to be no overall checking of good governance.
Ian Tupman
17 December 2017Cumbria Tourism is supporting the planning application for the Thirlmere zip wires. From their website ;
'Cumbria Tourism's aim is to be the UK's leading Tourist Board. Find out how we can help your business achieve more today'
Well, the answer may be to get a place on the Executive Board like Mike Turner who just happens to be a director of Treetop Treks.
And it would be interesting to here from Eric Robson, chairman of Cumbria Tourism and lover of all things Lakeland
REPLY
Stuart Miller
17 December 2017How can a charity formed specifically with the aims of
" promoting the conservation, protection and improvement of the physical and natural environment and cultural heritage of the Lake District by providing funding and support for conservation, environmental and cultural initiatives in the Lake District and Cumbria."
be neutral in such a proposal as the zip line when that is so obviously against those aims.
they should be proud to have spokesman willing to state such views.
simon noble
17 December 2017Who says Cumbria Tourism is a charity? CT is a company with directors. It represents its members' interests. It's web address should end .co.uk and not .org. You won't easily find minutes of meetings. Their surveys cost an arm and a leg. But their current research newsletters are free. The absolutely ridiculous thing is this. Read the latest one and you'd think, wow isn't the LD tourist economy doing really well. The headline says "Fourth consecutive year of growth for tourism". Why the need for theme park style rides?
KateC
18 December 2017I'd say well done for standing up for what you believe in and having the guts to do it very publicly. We need more people to be prepared to do this and not be cowed into remaining silent. Thank you to Mr Abraham for drawing more attention to this preposterous application.
Ian Tupman
18 December 2017It is also worth noting that Cumbria Tourism (which is supporting the zip wire proposal) has two main Patrons, one of which is United Utilities which coincidentally(?) owns Thirlmere.
SH
18 December 2017There clearly appears to be a number of conflicts of interest here which if true, suggest that Treetop Tricks, sorry I mean 'Treks', would not be fit partners for any development in the Lake District. This alleged level of vested interest and conflicts of interest needs to be dealt with robustly and opposed. If I wanted someone as a partner in business, I would want those with attributes like honesty, integrity and responsibility. Well done Terry Abraham for what is a courageous stance. I'd also encourage people to support him in his work and buy his DVDs (disclaimer: I don't know Terry at all)
Keitn Wren
18 December 2017A man of principle - unlike some who claim to have conservation at heart and then run for cover at the first challenge.
TH
18 December 2017Eric Robson now needs to seriously rethink his position. As Chairman of the Wainwright Society, does he really want to remain on the Executive Board of Cumbria Tourism?
sally bohling
18 December 2017Bravo, Terry - I admire your stance over this - there seem to be more conflict of interests at stake, than was initially apparent.
As Edmund Burke said :- "The only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing"!
Frances Bell
14 January 2018Nurture Cumbria Ltd states its objectives to be conservation of environment and heritage.
The Lake District Tourism conglomerate, including the above, states the its aim is to increase numbers of visitors.
These two are incompatible. It seems to me, reading about the members and their connections, that it's got a hint of witches brew. It needs to clean itself up and recognise that an area of superb environment, with the peace and abundance of birds and mammals and vegetation now disappearing from urban bits of Europe and the world, will attract visitors and pretty affluent visitors at that. We might, then, even, like the Galapagos Islands, find we are a stand-out popular destination.