The British Mountaineering Council has performed a u-turn on its decision earlier this year to rebrand itself Climb Britain.
Following strong criticism of the move from many of its members, the Manchester-based organisation began a consultation process.
Its president and chief executive announced on Friday it would be abandoning plans to change its name.
It will now continue as the British Mountaineering Council. Critics of the planned name change said it did not reflect that fact that many members are not climbers, but rather were hillwalkers or took part in other mountain activities.
They said the proposed name appeared to exclude non-climbers in the organisation.
President Rehan Siddiqui and chief executive Dave Turnbull said: “During the first three weeks of September the BMC held 12 consultation meetings across England and Wales to explain the thinking behind Climb Britain and listen to members’ views and concerns.
“Each meeting was attended by at least one senior BMC official or staff member – president, director, CEO or deputy CEO – and our national council met on 17 September to review the feedback. Written comments from individuals and clubs were also taken into account in this process.
“A strong consensus emerged in the meetings and as a result we can now confirm that national council has formally decided that the BMC will not be rebranding as Climb Britain.
“During the consultation process there was also general support for the idea of Climb Britain being put to some other use within the BMC, eg as a promotional campaign or marketing initiative. Over the next two months we will be assessing the options before reporting back to national council in December.
“We have learnt some very important lessons from this experience – not least that members feel a strong sense of ownership in the BMC and want to be actively involved with major organisational decisions.
“The BMC is an unusually diverse organisation with a rich heritage and a dedicated workforce of staff and volunteers. We remain strong and healthy and will continue to do our utmost to represent the wide range of activities within our overall ‘mountaineering’ remit – be it hillwalking, bouldering, competition climbing, ski mountaineering, indoor climbing, traditional or sport climbing and all aspects of winter mountaineering and ice climbing.”
In July, Mr Turnbull revealed the council had received about £25,000 from Sport England, the Government-backed agency, for a look at how the BMC was perceived and how it might improve its image, particularly among young people.
He admitted the suggested change in branding initially surprised him. “At the outset my expectation was that we’d probably end up with a recommendation to adopt a new BMC logo and some detailed brand guidelines about how to position ourselves.
“There was no specific brief to come up with new name for the BMC. It just evolved that way because the consultants came up with idea we felt had traction. For years we’ve pondered about the suitability of ‘mountaineering council’ in our name, but we’ve never been able to come up with an acceptable alternative.
“BMC as an acronym is OK if you know the BMC, but for new people it’s not obvious who we are or what we do.”
A simultaneous change in name for the sister organisation the Mountaineering Council of Scotland provoked little controversy. It consulted its members before the change to Mountaineering Scotland.
Nige
23 September 2016Good. How about dropping the Britain altogether as it is not a British organisation?
Madcarew
23 September 2016Well done BMC; downclimbing on 'Climb Britain' was the right thing to do.
When the dust has settled it may be worth addressing the 'Britain' issue, and maybe dropping 'Council'
Mountaineering England (& Wales)?
P Cook
24 September 2016“We have learnt some very important lessons from this experience – not least that members feel a strong sense of ownership in the BMC and want to be actively involved with major organisational decisions.
It still amazes me that the National Council had bypassed the membership directly abandoning its own equality statement in essentially what is a membership organisation. This breach of one owns statements from the leadership involved in this fiasco, warrants more in depth scrutiny from an external non-biased source. Perhaps the £25K would have been better spent of leadership and management training; where those involved in this sad event would have learnt how to recognise that a membership organisation is essentially owned by the members!
RobGregory
24 September 2016Well done on going back to the BMC. Suggest we leave it as that (rather than dropping the B and/or the C as some seem to advocate). "The BMC" and "the British Mountaineering Council" are statements that are distinctive and have stature and brand awareness - they don't need to be descriptively completely 100% accurate; it's (still) not broke so let's not fix it.
Lake Shaw
24 September 2016I agree with their comment that Newbies will not know what BMC stands for but these days it is only a Google away. Hikers do manage to find their way to BMC.
David Faulkner
24 September 2016Good.
Wilf from Keswick
25 September 2016I can’t help but laugh when I read this type of thing.
Life really is quite short so instead of getting upset and arguing about this sort of rubbish wouldn’t it be better to get out there and enjoy the places you are apparently so bothered about.
OB
25 September 2016If some people enjoy debating this kind of thing, good for them. Live and let live.
Margaret
26 September 2016P Cook - I suspect that 'leadership and management training' may have been part of the problem.
John Manning
26 September 2016The right decision … but one that needn't have had to have been taken in the first place. "Climb down" is the right phrase.
The BMC has represented many activities – walking, climbing, mountaineering, back country skiing, etc etc – and the proposed new name was all, it seemed to me, for the sake of the "sport" element of climbing, which itself encompasses a far wider base (some folk actually do it for outdoor recreation, for example).
I hope no more effort, energy, time and money is wasted thinking about another name for the membership to reject.
TH
26 September 2016I know that "consultants" were definitely part of the problem.
BF
02 April 2017Since 'Rehan Siddiqui' became leader of BMC. it was renamed 'Climb', and stars a Polish Julia Bradbury. You couldn't accuse him of populism.