A community group trying to buy a Lake District mountain insists it is still in negotiations to take over the property.
Confusion has surrounded the fate of Blencathra after agents told journalists last November that the land had been taken off the market.
The Friends of Blencathra was set up shortly after the original announcement that the mountain would be sold off to raise cash to pay an inheritance tax bill following the death of its owner the Earl of Lonsdale.
Speculation has been rife about the fate of the Lake District fell, described by author Alfred Wainwright as ‘the mountaineers’ mountain’.
The Friends released a statement at the weekend saying it was still trying to buy Blencathra and was the vendor’s preferred choice to take over ownership.
The group said: “The tale involving the charity is an extraordinary one. The Blencathra mountain, about 2,000 acres, was brought to the market on 5 May 2014 with a tight time scale for sealed bids and a guide price of £1.75m.
“The vendor’s intention – the estate of the late Earl of Lonsdale – was to pay off an inheritance tax debt using the sale proceeds.
“Once aware of the proposed sale, and with the idea of the Big Society planted in their minds, a group of local people decided to try to secure ownership of the mountain for the public benefit. Their fear was that the mountain might otherwise be bought by unsympathetic private interests.”
The Friends said a QC, Janet Turner, of Berwin, Leighton Paisner volunteered her help and, at her suggestion, she was joined by Michael Fiddes of Strutt & Parker in offering their expertise to the charity.
In June 2014, with Ms Turner’s help, the charity succeeded in registering the mountain as a community asset under the Localism Act.
The Friends raised several hundred thousand pounds in a few weeks with donations from the public but also secured a major pledge from the company that owns the Berghaus outdoor brand.
The group’s statement said: “It put in a sealed bid on 1 July 2014 based on professional advice as to valuation. The amount offered included an anticipated grant of £500,000 from the Community Asset capital grant scheme phase due to close at the end of July 2014. The latter grant opportunity was lost as the charity’s offer was not accepted in time.
“The charity has maintained constant contact with the vendor’s lawyers over the last 18 months. The decision-making process on the vendor’s side has been a long and complicated one.
“However the position is as follows: the mountain has not been sold to other bidders; the vendor is committed to the sale of the mountain; the vendor would prefer to sell to the charity provided that acceptable terms can be agreed.
“To that end the charity submitted a revised draft contract of sale to the vendor in November 2015. Today, the terms of that deal remain under discussion between the parties.”
The Friends of Blencathra added that the bid details are confidential. They also said the funds raised so far had to be used for the potential purchase of Blencathra and could not be diverted to help Cumbria flood victims.
“While the charity has every sympathy with those affected by the terrible recent local floods, it is constrained in its expenditure of those funds,” they said.
“The trustee directors have been advised, and accept, that the charity’s funds cannot be spent on flood relief.”
MuddyBoots
18 April 2016Rubbish. The mountain isn't for sale anymore. They are 33 days late in submitting their accounts to the Charity Commission and are blocking concerned donators on social media when they ask genuine questions. Even their website has been down for weeks so contact is limited. Donators are concerned that they may lose their money to a potential scam...
Lake District lover
24 April 2016I endorse the anxiety above & would like advice on reclaiming the money I donated in good faith. Anyone with any ideas on this?
Angus Mckibbin
02 May 2016I donate £100 recently through Charities aid foundation --what has happened to that? maybe the Friends would like to comment.
Given Up Hope
05 May 2016On 2 occasions I requested most of my donation to be returned so that I could donate it to a more worthwhile charity but was refused.
MuddyBoots
13 May 2016This isn't good. They have their AGM this Saturday. I wonder if they'll still tell people the sale is going ahead 'but it's taking time'! I did post contact links on here previously but it wasn't published. Anyway, good luck in getting your donations back. It's a real shame that something started with great intentions, has now become a big bone of contention and is shrouded in distrust.
John
13 May 2016I have supported the FOB albeit quietly and from a distance since the beginning, I made a payment in the very early days on the understanding that if the Mountain was not bought by the group all moneys over £10 would be repaid.
Currently it is taking time and unfortunately there appears to be lots of criticism of the group from within. I would hope that following the soon to be held AGM that we hear some positive feedback. Also that the end is in sight, this has been going on for over two years and needs to be resolved soon.
I am not having a go at any side in this long running saga but just want some plain speaking from FOB and the truth.
David Hall
23 May 2016It very sad to read about the delays and lack of updates regarding the purchase of Blencathra. The idea is a novel but exciting approach to the future ownership of the mountain. I have happy memories of climbing Saddleback many years ago.
I made a contribution and encouraged my friends do the same. Sadly it seems to have gone sour. Attempts to contact the "friends" have proved unsuccessful. I hope that a response will emerge from the AGM and clarification given soon about the project and where the money is. Perhaps an appeal to the SAGA magazine to revisit the topic and publish their findings would shine a strong spotlight on the topic. From a disappointed potential part owner of a mountain.
MuddyBoots
25 May 2016Unfortunately, if the sale is successful (extremely remote now according to the Telegraph 5 days ago), the only 'owners' of the mountain will be the Charity, NOT the donators. I think that has been particularly misleading from the start - in giving people the idea that their donation will purchase them a part of the mountain. Not so. Perhaps though, it was initially a cleverly unintentional ruse to get people to part with their money in the first place! They haven't got a clue how to run a 'charity'. Sadly, had they not got rid of the decent members of the board/group etc a long time ago.....there wouldn't be this discussion now.
Dave Hall
01 July 2016It is now 1 July 2016. Has their been any progress on this sad debacle?
MuddyBoots
23 July 2016Nope. They're still insisting they are still buying Blencathra. I feel for those who have donated... Blind faith never gets you anywhere!