A planned 14-week closure of the main road alongside Loch Lomond to the Highlands could sound the death knell for the recovering Scottish winter sports industry.
The Scottish Government has approved the building of a viaduct to carry the A82 trunk road at Pulpit Rock, between Tarbet and Crianlarich.
The narrow section of the busy road to many Highland walking, climbing and skiing venues is a notorious bottleneck with traffic lights allowing only alternate one-way traffic, with resulting long queues at peak tourist times.
The road carries a large amount of traffic between Glasgow and Fort William, from large goods vehicles and tourist coaches to numerous cars carrying outdoors enthusiasts to the mountains of the western Highlands.
But the work will mean a total closure of the route for three months, with a diversion via Rest and Be Thankful and Inveraray before returning to Tyndrum via Dalmally and the A85. The alternative route will add 30 miles (48km) to the journey. It is estimated the journey will take at least an hour longer.
Skiing experts have urged planners to put the works back to the late autumn. The road closure is currently scheduled to begin in January 2012 and to be in force until April – covering the peak period for skiing and winter climbing and hillwalking.
With daylight hours at a premium for those venturing on to the hills in winter, a delay of an extra 60 minutes could be crucial in making a trip viable or not.
Snowsport Scotland, the national governing body for skiing and snowboarding said: “It will be near enough equidistant from Glasgow to Glenshee, Cairngorm and Glencoe and further to Nevis Range: so a very early start to all day trips and potentially a devastating outcome for the financial viability of Glencoe Mountain Resort.”
A consultation by Transport Scotland ended yesterday, and the results are awaited before a final decision on the timing of the closure is made. One reason for the winter closure is to minimise wildlife disruption, particularly to otters and bats in the area. The road planners intend to install artificial otter holts and bat roosting locations.
In addition to the 14-week closure, the roadworks necessary for the improvement, which will see a 180m viaduct constructed to carry traffic over the waters at the northern end of Loch Lomond will need a realignment of the road over 400m and a speed limit of 20mph or 30mph will be imposed during this work. Delays are inevitable, and the whole project is likely to run to 12 months.
In February this year, the Glencoe ski resort, on the northern slopes of Meall a’ Bhùiridh, was the snowiest in the world, with a 24-hour snowfall of 80cm – more than any other ski slopes worldwide at the time.
Scottish ski resorts had their best season in decades last winter, with some reporting skiing right into June. But poor snowfalls in previous years had left many resorts in a parlous financial state, with new owners taking over the Glencoe ski centre last winter.
- The ‘temporary’ traffic lights at Pulpit Rock, on the most winding section of the lochside road, celebrated their 30th birthday recently and gained a brief unofficial adornment of balloons to celebrate the occasion.
Nearby Pulpit Rock was excavated under the direction of the Rev Peter Proudfoot in the mid 19th century and was a meeting place for Free Church congregations until a church was built at Ardlui. It is protected as a scheduled ancient monument.
Roy
06 November 2010Well, as a skier of 35 years in Scotland, this comes as an unsensitive whammy. Yup, we all all love wildlife, but I'm afraid the human lives come first. Yup, we all know that the road needs improving but is there not a better solution?
rhodesy
06 November 2010So at a time when the country is trying to escape recession, they're more bothered about not bothering bats and otters than they are about destroying a rural economy.
matterhorn
07 November 2010Whats the problem there are alternative routes--Get up earlier!!!!!!!
VCMac
07 November 2010To drive from Glasgowalong the A80 then the A84 through Callander, joining the A82 at Crianlarich will really not add much to your journey time. We often use this route to avoid the A82 at Loch Lomond. The roadworks on the A80 will be complete and it will be motorway standard from Glasgow to Stirling. It's about time the A82 got upgraded!
John Beaton
07 November 2010Pulpit rock is by no means the biggest bottle neck on the A82. Any one travelling the road at busy periods will tell you the tail back from Balloch roundabout, Duck bay and Arden roundabout can back up all the way to Inverbeg which is a real nightmare when returning down lochlomond at the end of the day.
Pulpit rock is a minor inconvenience by comparison
munro bob
07 November 2010when is the right time ?????
Spiller
07 November 2010For anyone travelling from the East of Glasgow, the route named by VCMac is quicker than using the A82. It's only people in the West end of Glasgow, or Clydebank, Dumbarton, and places South of Ardlui who will take any longer to get to Glencoe. The disruption will no doubt be a pain, but the road is 50 years overdue for upgrading, and it's only for 14 weeks.
Jim Osborne
07 November 2010Can't agree with Roy and rhodesy at all. Unless we start protecting bio-diversity humans are finished as a species in the longer run. Its well beoynd time that wildlife, the environment and conservation took precedence over short term money-making and "the economy" - the economy will just have to adapt. Presumably the Scottish Executive have over-ruled the Park Authority who I assume objected to the upgrade proposal itself since even the building of a viaduct at this location will be adverse environmental impacts itself. Ah well, say bye-bye to another piece of wild land. I can't imagine the John Muir rust are too enamoured with the project either.
nan
10 November 2010got to agree with jim osborne here. the closure will be a pain in the arse and will affect my commute to work [though not to skiing as i am lucky enough to live north of the closure ] but surely our delicate ecosystems deserve protecting? or at least harm reduction! inconvienience to us is a small price to pay!
A hilly
02 December 2011fully agree with rhodesy i'm afraid that the bats and otters will have to move else ware, if they destroy the rural economy we will be out hunting the bats and otters for the dinner table insted of trying to protect them.